Evidence Family

REF evidencefamily.com · 7 November 2026

Repetition is not corroboration

How wire copy and syndication spread one source across many stories, the sourcing standards newsrooms publish, and how to trace a story back upstream.

Wires and syndication

  1. Attribution terms explained

    What common attribution phrases signal about where a fact came from, and what published newsroom codes in the US, UK and Germany say about using them.

  2. Copyright exceptions for news reporting

    How the Berne Convention, the EU, the UK, the US and Canada let news outlets reuse others' work for reporting, and the acknowledgement each one requires.

  3. News bargaining laws compared

    How Australia's code, Canada's Online News Act and France's related-rights regime push platforms to pay news publishers, with dates and amounts.

  4. Photo credit lines and embedded metadata

    What the IPTC Credit Line, Source, Creator and Copyright Notice fields record, how they differ, and what US and UK law says about removing them.

  5. Press publishers' rights in the EU, France and Germany

    How Article 15 of the EU copyright directive gives publishers a two-year right over online uses, and how France and Germany apply it.

  6. Wire services and syndication explained

    How the big news agencies are owned and governed, how members and clients reuse agency copy, and what published rules say about crediting it.

Sourcing standards

  1. Circular reporting explained

    How one source can look like many, what newsroom guides and US intelligence reviews say about it, and the checks that published standards set out.

  2. Corroboration rules in criminal law

    Where criminal law still requires two independent sources of evidence, from Scotland's general rule to perjury and treason, and where it was abolished.

  3. How to trace a story to its source

    A step-by-step method for following a claim upstream through credits, agency copy, documents and file provenance, based on published rules.

  4. Intelligence sourcing standards explained

    How US Intelligence Community Directives 203 and 206 require analysts to cite, describe and weigh their sources, and what official reviews found.

  5. Press council codes on accuracy and sourcing compared

    What seven press codes, from the UK to South Africa and Kenya, say about verifying facts, rumours, anonymous sources and corrections.

  6. Single-source and two-source rules

    What published newsroom codes say about confirming facts with two independent sources, when one source is allowed, and how unconfirmed claims are treated.

  7. Source reliability grading systems explained

    How UK police guidance, the Europol Regulation and US intelligence directives grade a source and its information apart, and where corroboration fits.

  8. Sourcing and provenance glossary

    Official definitions of sourcing, corroboration and provenance terms from intelligence directives, EU law, C2PA, IPTC, ICMJE, COPE and Cochrane.

Provenance

  1. AI-generated content labelling laws

    What the EU AI Act, China's 2025 rules and California's AI Transparency Act require for marking AI-generated content, with dates and penalties.

  2. C2PA Content Credentials explained

    How the C2PA standard attaches signed provenance records to images, video and other files, what those records prove, and what they do not.

  3. Clinical trial registration explained

    How ICMJE, WHO, US and EU rules make trials record their plans and results in public registries, with the deadlines, data items and registries that count.

  4. Duplicate publication rules in research

    What the ICMJE Recommendations say about duplicate and secondary publication, preprints and registry results, and why it matters for evidence.

  5. Multiple reports of one study: how reviews link them

    How the Cochrane Handbook, PRISMA 2020 and ICMJE rules stop one study from being counted as several, and the criteria used to link reports.

  6. Retractions and corrections in research

    What COPE, ICMJE and US research misconduct rules say about corrections, retractions and expressions of concern, and how to check a paper's status.